Newsdesk
The new May, 2010 Special Report edition of Soundings is now available on-line. Please visit our Publications Section.
UKDC Seminar in Hamburg 20th May, 2010
Over 70 members of the local shipping community attended a recent seminar at the Atlantic Hotel in Hamburg hosted by the Managers of the UK Defence Club and UK P&I Club. A team from the Managers, joined by Julian Clark from Holman Fenwick Willan, enacted a role play to illustrate some of the charterparty issues that can arise when a ship is ordered to transit the Gulf Of Aden. The fictitious panamax bulk carrier the ATLANTIC was ordered to proceed on a voyage from Romania to China via the Gulf of Aden. The cast of characters explored the legal issues arising from this order and the rights of both owner and charterer. The role play then moved on to deal with the owner having agreed to undertake the voyage on a without prejudice basis and the charterer remitting hire into an escrow account. Matters did not rest there however as nearing the end of the fixture the charterer gave an approximate "wp" 30 day re-delivery notice which he subsequently revised intending to send the ship on a final voyage. After some discussion about the impact of the decision of the Court of Appeal in the ZENOVIA, the owner took the decision to terminate the charter as he was committed to a subsequent fixture.
Unable to reach an amicable solution to their dispute, arbitrators were appointed by the owner and the charterer however they agreed to put the arbitration on hold whilst they attempted to mediate. The role play then moved to the mediation where the parties discussed whether it was possible to find an appropriate compromise.
The owner of the ship was played very convincingly by Paul Kaye, with German market underwriter, Jason Riley, embracing the role of the charterer. Alison McClure, undertook the role as the owner's claims handler, with Philip Clacy, the owner's London solicitor. Tarja Saikkonen played the role of the charterer's London solicitor and Julian Clark, (an accredited CEDR mediator), played the role of mediator. Susanne Murphy as narrator ensured that the story flowed.
At the conclusion of the role play Andrew Ward of Thomas Miller War Risks outlined to the audience key issues affecting the industry when viewed from the perspective of a war risk underwriter.
The evening concluded with a drinks reception and the raffling of two of the props used during the seminar - congratulations to Rainer Lochbaum of Rudolf A Oetker who won the pirate and a bottle of his favourite beverage and also to Jan van Bocksen of ER Schiffahrt who won the pirate's parrot.
The new March edition of Soundings is now available. Please visit our Publications section to see this and all other issues.
Bob Crawford calls time on his work
for Thomas Miller mutuals
Airports Limited (1986-1993). He was awarded a CBE in 1990 for services to Scottish aviation.
Bob was appointed a director of the UK Defence Club in 1976 and served as Chairman from 1987 to 1990. He was a Director of the UK P&I Club from 1980 to 1994 and Chairman from 1983 to 1990. He contributed to the formation of Jurinflot and chaired the Russian maritime legal organisation during its ownership by the London group of P&I clubs.
He became a Director of the UK War Risks Club in 1980 and Chairman two years later, a role discharged continuously for 28 years. His watch took in two Gulf wars and the Falklands conflict. Between 1987 and 1990, therefore, Bob Crawford was Chairman of three Thomas Miller-managed clubs.
He has lately been concerned with Somali piracy issues. Last year, he took a cruise through the Gulf of Aden which meant following the Somali "corridor."
Hugo Wynn-Williams maintained that the breadth and extent of Bob’s involvement in marine mutuals was almost certainly unmatched, having attended 286 board meetings across the three clubs. He had worked with Bob on a number of international cases and had greatly benefitted from his advice.
Bob Crawford has some broad comments on marine mutuals.
"During my chairmanship of the UK Club, we did not face the same regulatory and financial issues which confront today’s P&I boards. I was particularly keen to stimulate real contributions from such an international and culturally diverse set of directors. This could be quite a challenge with 30 people of 15 nationalities who, between them, ran a substantial part of the world maritime fleet. However, participation certainly improved. "The Defence Club was characterised by thoroughgoing debate and discussion over claims, enhanced by the extensive personal knowledge and experience of the owner and senior executive members of the board. They have also had to deal increasingly with EU regulatory requirements.
"In my 30 years on the board, the UK War Risks Club has enjoyed a relatively smooth ride with few heavy claims, costs kept in check and returns of call. This occurred in the context of exceptional growth from 70 entered vessels at the outset to well over 800 today. I anticipate that the incidence of piracy well off the Somali coast will increase, given the sophisticated nature of some operations. We need strong sanctions from the United Nations if we are to deal properly with piracy.
"The mutual concept is something that merchant fleets should be pleased exists. Clubs face a difficult battle with the commercial market in providing an insurance product. Having dealt with the P&I clubs since I was at Ince & Co, I have found a high standard of competence and a massive emphasis on personal service."
Outside marine matters, Bob once owned three cattle breeding farms in Scotland and still shoots. His first wife Rita, a Latvian whom he married in 1947, died a few years ago. He remarried earlier this year.
As a Director of Thomas Miller-managed mutuals, 86-year-old Bob Crawford has decided to call it a day, having notched up 78 years of service spread across three clubs. He has just retired as Chairman of the UK War Risks Club and as a Director of the UK Defence Club after meetings on April 14th and 15th. He is a former Chairman of the UK Defence and UK P&I Club boards and, from 1987 to 1990, presided over all three organisations.
He was presented with a sterling silver quaich, made in Glasgow in 1937 at Trinity House, London on April 14th, at a reception attended by directors and managers with whom he had worked and associates in shipping, transportation and related services. The presentation was made by Hugo Wynn-Williams, Chairman of Thomas Miller.
Bob Crawford was born on 20 March 1924 and brought up in north east Scotland, where he attended Robert Gordon’s College, Aberdeen. He was in the RAF from 1942-47, qualifying as a navigator and serving in South Africa and Germany.
After demobilisation, he became articled to Lewin Gregory Torr & Durnford in London, qualifying as a solicitor in 1950. He worked briefly for Thorold Brodie & Mason in Westminster before moving to Ince & Co to specialise in shipping and marine insurance work. He remained there for 22 years, becoming a partner and playing a major role in the growth of Ince’s business.
He was heavily involved with major Greek, Turkish and Asian ship owners and with leading personalities in international shipping, including Aristotle Onassis, C Y Tung and Boris Vlasov. His high profile cases included the Seawise University, formerly the Queen Elizabeth, destroyed by fire in Hong Kong; and the seizure of the Onassis whaling fleet by the Peruvian government.
In 1974, Bob was persuaded by Boris Vlasov to leave Ince and become, initially, Group Managing Director of Shipping Industrial Holdings Ltd on Vlasov’s takeover of the large shipping conglomerate. The role included the chairmanship of Silver Line Ltd, its principal ship owning company. Shortly after, Bob became President of the Vlasov group worldwide, based in Monte Carlo. He retired from active participation in 1983 but chaired the Silver Line pension fund until 18 months ago.
He held board and other appointments with Lloyds Register of Shipping (1982-2004) and was a trustee of their pension fund until 2008. Other board appointments have included the Civil Aviation Authority (1984-1993), the Port of London Authority (1985-1992) and Highlands and Islands
The Rules of the Association 2010/2011 Circular and EGM are now available online. Please visit our Publications Section.
The new March edition of Soundings is now available online. Please visit our Publications Section.
Claims Syndicate Reorganisation
As part of our continuing effort to ensure that Members receive optimal service for claims handling and account management, the current London claims Area Groups structure will be re-formed into three syndicates. These syndicates aim to deliver the most appropriate resources are available to the needs and circumstances of our membership.
Paul Sessions will become the Syndicate Manager for “London Syndicate 1” which will look after the interests of Members based in Japan, Turkey, Russia, India, Pakistan and the Middle East.
Philip Clacy will be Syndicate Manager for “London Syndicate 2” which will service Members based in Greece and Germany, Italy, France, Spain, Switzerland, Croatia, Scandinavia, North and South Africa.
Upon her return from maternity leave, Susanne Murphy will continue in her role in the UK Defence Club management team and contribute to German Member service.
Further information on the logistical and IT changes necessary to support this reorganisation will follow in due course. In the meantime, please continue with your current arrangements when communicating with the Club.
If you have any questions about any of these changes then please feel free to consult your usual Club contact or alternatively Daniel Evans, Club Manager London.
This Circular is now available. Please visit our Publications Section.