') right .25rem center no-repeat content-box border-box #25303b;color:#fff;border:0;padding:.5rem 1rem;font-size:1rem}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters form .search{margin:0 0 1rem;width:100%;text-align:left;padding:.5rem 1rem;height:2.5rem;background:rgba(37,48,59,.6);font-size:1rem}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters form .search::before{float:right;font-size:1.1rem}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters form .search span{padding:0;display:block}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter div.categories ul li{background-image:none;padding:0}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter span.field{display:block;padding:0;width:100%}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter span.label{display:none}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter span.field input.radio,div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter span.field input.checkbox{width:auto}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters button{margin-bottom:1.4em;clear:both}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li{float:left;margin:0;width:2.7em;height:2.7em;line-height:2.7em;background:#f2f2f2;color:#666}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li span{float:left;background-image:none;background-color:rgba(0,59,117,.3);color:rgba(255,255,255,.75);padding:0;margin:0;width:2.7em;height:2.7em;line-height:2.7em;text-align:center}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li a span{background-color:#003b75;color:#fff;-webkit-transition:background .2s;-moz-transition:background .2s;transition:background .2s}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li a:hover span{background-color:#25303b}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li.active,div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li.active a span{background-color:#fff;color:#003b75}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li.active a{color:currentColor}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li.active span,div.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li.active span{background-color:#fff;color:currentColor}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.ilters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li.active span{color:#000}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul{margin:0}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.users.filters div.filter.alphabetical div.options ul li a{background-image:none;padding:0}.knowledge.filters form{margin-bottom:1rem}.knowledge.filters button{margin-left:0}.knowledge.filters .filter{width:100%}.knowledge.filters .filter+.search{float:none}.knowledge.filters .filter .label{display:block;width:100%}.knowledge.filters .filter .field{width:100%}.knowledge.filters .filter.keywords .label{display:block;padding-bottom:.5em}.knowledge.filters .filter.keywords input{border:thin solid #ccc;padding:.5rem 1rem;min-height:2.5rem;max-width:100%}.filters .filter.keywords+.search{display:inline-block;vertical-align:bottom;font-size:1rem;width:100%;max-width:none;padding:0 1rem;margin:0}.filters .filter.keywords+.search::before{font-size:100%;display:inline-block}.knowledge.filters form select{-webkit-appearance:none;-moz-appearance:none;appearance:none;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml;utf8, ");background-origin:content-box;background-position:right 0 center;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:.5625rem .375rem;border-radius:0;border:0;font-size:1rem;margin-bottom:0;min-height:2.5rem;padding:.5rem 1rem;width:100%}.knowledge.filters form select:focus,.knowledge.filters form select:active{outline:0}.knowledge.filters form .search{width:100%}.knowledge.filters form .search span{margin-left:.5rem}div.knowledge.filters button.search span{display:inline-block}div.offices div.mapContainer{width:auto}div.tx-llcatalog-pi div.offices{margin-left:0}div.quote{border:0;background-color:#e2e2e2}div.quote blockquote{line-height:1.5;color:#003b75;font-size:1.1rem;font-weight:400;font-style:normal;padding:1rem 1.5rem}div.quote blockquote::after{display:none}div.quote p.author{color:#25303b;font-style:normal;padding:0 1.5rem 1.5rem}div.featureBox>div.content h2{color:#000;background:0 0;padding:0}div.featureBox .csc-textpic-intext-left .csc-textpic-imagewrap{margin-right:0;clear:both;display:block;float:none;padding-top:1.5rem}div.featureBox .csc-textpic-intext-left .csc-textpic-imagewrap img{max-height:11.5rem;width:auto;display:block;margin:0 auto;-webkit-box-shadow:0 .1rem 1rem 0 rgba(17,17,17,.25);box-shadow:0 .1rem 1rem 0 rgba(17,17,17,.25)}#secondaryNavigation~div>a.download.pdf{padding:0}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content{padding:0 0 .1em;border:0;background:#f4f4f4;color:#003b75;font-size:105%}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne a>.featureBox>.content{-webkit-transition:.4s;-moz-transition:.4s;transition:.4s}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne a>.featureBox>.content:hover>div:not(.csc-textpic){background-color:#003b75;color:#fff}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne a>.featureBox>.content:hover img{-webkit-transform:scale(1.05);-moz-transform:scale(1.05);-ms-transform:scale(1.05);transform:scale(1.05);opacity:.8}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne a>.featureBox>.content img{will-change:transform,opacity;-webkit-transition:.4s;-moz-transition:.4s;transition:.4s}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne a>.featureBox>.content>div{-webkit-transition:.4s;-moz-transition:.4s;transition:.4s}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox .csc-textpic-text,.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content>div>.wrapper{padding:.7em 1em .7em 3em;background:url('/assets/uk-defence/img/icon-chevronCircleBlue.png') 1em .8em no-repeat;min-height:2em;color:inherit}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox .csc-textpic-text{padding-top:0;background-position-y:.1em}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content h2,.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content h3,.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content h4{background:0 0;font-size:110%;padding:0;margin-bottom:.2em}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content p{line-height:1.4;margin-bottom:0}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content p a{color:#fff;padding:0;background:0 0}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content .csc-textpic,.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content img{margin-bottom:0}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content .csc-textpic-center-outer,.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .featureBox>.content .csc-textpic-center-inner{position:static;float:none}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .floatingBox{border:.2em solid #dedfe0;padding:1em 1em 1em 6.5em;min-height:4em;background:#fff}.pageLayout>div>.columnOne .floatingBox>.content{padding-top:.5em}div.userList div.twoColumnLayout.thirtySeventy div.columnOne,div.userSingle div.twoColumnLayout.thirtySeventy div.columnOne{max-width:75px}#c41179 .box.page.grey{margin-bottom:0}#c41391 div.box.page.grey{clear:both;background:url('/assets/uk-defence/img/map.png') 50% top no-repeat #f4f4f4;height:200px;text-align:center;margin-bottom:0;border-top:4px solid #d5d8db;border-bottom:4px solid #d5d8db}#c41391 div.box.page.grey div.content{text-align:center;width:90%;padding-top:2em}#c41391 div.box.page.grey h2{text-transform:uppercase;color:#003b75;border-bottom:1px solid #b4b4b4;letter-spacing:.3em;background-image:none;font-size:120%}#c41391 div.box.page.grey p{font-size:110%;color:#4d4d4d}#home #c41391 div.box.page.grey h2{font-size:150%;font-weight:400}div.columnTwo #c41391 div.box.page.grey{height:auto;margin-bottom:1em;border:4px solid #d5d8db;float:none;width:auto}div.columnTwo #c41391 div.box.page.grey div.content{padding-top:1em}.box.page.grey p.button{margin-bottom:1.5rem}#home div.pageLayout{padding-bottom:0}#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout{margin:4rem 0 1rem;text-align:center}#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout h3{color:#003b75;font-weight:400;font-size:1rem}#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout img{margin-bottom:1rem;height:4rem!important;width:auto}#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout .column{width:50%;display:inline-block;vertical-align:top;margin-left:-.5rem;padding:0 .5rem;-webkit-box-sizing:border-box;-moz-box-sizing:border-box;box-sizing:border-box}#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout .column.columnTwo,#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout .column.columnFour{border-left:.125rem solid #e2e2e2}#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout .column.columnThree,#home .box.page div.fourColumnLayout .column.columnFour{border-top:.125rem solid #e2e2e2;padding-top:1rem}#home .box.page.grey{margin-bottom:2rem}#home .box.page.grey>.content{padding:2rem 1rem}#home .box.page.grey .csc-textpic-text{margin-top:1em}#home div.knowledgeBaseList.summary ul li{background:0 0;padding-left:0}#home div.knowledgeBaseList.summary ul li:not(:last-child){margin-bottom:1rem;padding-bottom:1rem;border-bottom:.125rem solid #e2e2e2}#home div.layout.twoColumnLayout.seventyThirty div.fiftyFifty div.column div.columnWrapper p{line-height:1.5em}#home .box.page.grey .twoColumnLayout .columnTwo .csc-firstHeader::before{content:'';background-image:url('/assets/uk-defence/img/icon-twitter.png');background-position:left center;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:1.6rem;padding-left:2rem}#home .box.page.grey .twoColumnLayout .article{text-align:center;display:inline-block;vertical-align:top;width:50%;padding:1rem;-webkit-box-sizing:border-box;-moz-box-sizing:border-box;box-sizing:border-box}#home .box.page.grey .twoColumnLayout .article:nth-child(odd){border-right:.125rem solid #e2e2e2;clear:left}#home .box.page.grey .twoColumnLayout .article h4{clear:both;padding-top:1rem}#home .box.page.grey .twoColumnLayout .article h4 a{font-weight:400;font-size:.8rem;color:#25303b;line-height:1.5}#home .box.page.grey .twoColumnLayout .article h4 a:hover{color:#003b75}#home .box.page.grey .twoColumnLayout .article img{width:auto;max-width:100%;border:0;padding:0;max-height:11.5rem}#home .box.page .threeColumnLayout .csc-textpic .csc-textpic-image img{-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover;height:100%!important;width:100%}#home .box.page .threeColumnLayout .csc-textpic .csc-textpic-text{padding:1rem}#home .box.page .threeColumnLayout .csc-textpic .csc-textpic-text h3{font-weight:400}#home .box.page .threeColumnLayout .csc-textpic .csc-textpic-text p{color:#47bcca;margin-bottom:.5rem}#home .box.page .threeColumnLayout .csc-textpic .csc-textpic-text p:last-child{color:#111;margin-bottom:0}#home div.royalSlider{position:relative;background-color:#e2e2e2}#home div.royalSlider.contentSlider>div{max-height:none}#home div.royalSlider .rsContainer{background-color:#003b75;max-height:none}#home div.royalSlider .rsContainer div.image img{position:absolute;left:50%;-webkit-transform:translateX(-50%) translateY(-50%);-moz-transform:translateX(-50%) translateY(-50%);-ms-transform:translateX(-50%) translateY(-50%);transform:translateX(-50%) translateY(-50%);min-width:100%;top:50%;min-height:30vh;width:auto}#home div.royalSlider .rsContainer .rsSlide{max-height:none}#home div.royalSlider.overlay div.content{min-height:13rem;max-width:73em;margin:0 auto;position:relative;padding:3rem 1rem}#home div.royalSlider.overlay div.content div.contentWrapper{position:absolute;bottom:3rem}#home div.royalSlider.overlay div.content div.contentBox{padding:0;color:#fff;font-weight:400;margin:0;background:0 0;text-shadow:0 0 1rem rgba(0,0,0,.5);font-size:2em;line-height:1.3;position:relative}#home div.royalSlider.overlay div.content div.contentBox::before{display:inline-block;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-image:url(/assets/uk-defence/img/sprite.svg?1614687539);background-size:12.688em 10.75em;width:5.062em;height:5.75em;background-position:-7.344em -4.719em;content:'';font-size:.5rem}#home div.royalSlider span.rsTmb{display:none}#home div.royalSlider.rsDefault .rsNavContainer{float:none;bottom:.5em;top:auto;left:0;right:0}#home div.royalSlider.rsDefault .rsNav{float:none;padding:0;text-align:center}#home div.royalSlider.rsDefault .rsBullet{margin:0 7px}#home div.royalSlider.rsDefault .rsNav .rsNavSelected span{background-color:#47bcca}#home div.royalSlider.rsDefault .rsNav span{background:#fff}#home div.royalSlider div.videoPlayer>video{display:none}#home div.royalSlider .contentBox>*{color:currentColor;font-size:1.5rem;line-height:1.3;font-weight:400;text-shadow:0 0 1rem rgba(74,74,74,.5);background:0 0;margin-bottom:1rem;max-width:-webkit-calc(100% - 4rem);max-width:-moz-calc(100% - 4rem);max-width:calc(100% - 4rem)}#signup label{width:10em;float:left}#signup input[type=submit]{width:auto;border:none;background-color:#aaa;color:#fff;padding:.5em .8em;margin:0 0 1em;overflow:visible;border-radius:.4em}#signup input[type=checkbox]~label{width:-webkit-calc(100% - 2rem);width:-moz-calc(100% - 2rem);width:calc(100% - 2rem);float:none;margin-left:0;display:inline-block;vertical-align:top}div.alertModal a{color:#47bcca}div.alertModal .button{background:#47bcca}div.alertModal>.wrapper{background-color:#003b75;border-top-color:#47bcca}.fwFeaturedQuote.fwBox{background:#25303b}.fwFeaturedQuote.fwBox blockquote{font-size:150%}.fwFeaturedQuote.fwBox .quote{border:0}.fwFeaturedQuote.fwBox .quote blockquote{color:#fff}.fwFeaturedQuote.fwBox .quote p.author{opacity:1}.fwFeaturedQuote.fwBox .quote p.author::before{background-color:#47bcca}.fwBreakout.fwBox[style*=background]::before{background:-webkit-gradient(linear,left top,right top,color-stop(30%,rgba(0,59,117,.9)),to(rgba(0,59,117,.5)));background:-webkit-linear-gradient(left,rgba(0,59,117,.9) 30%,rgba(0,59,117,.5));background:-moz-linear-gradient(left,rgba(0,59,117,.9) 30%,rgba(0,59,117,.5));background:linear-gradient(to right,rgba(0,59,117,.9) 30%,rgba(0,59,117,.5))}.routingBoxGroup>div>div>a .routingBox::after{-webkit-filter:invert(1) grayscale(.1) brightness(5.2) opacity(.8);filter:invert(1) grayscale(.1) brightness(5.2) opacity(.8)}
The task of quantifying the losses arising due to a breach of a contract of affreightment is not always straightforward. The recent decision in Palmali Shipping SA v Litasco SA [2020] EWHC 2581 (Comm) highlights the issues involved and provides welcome guidance. In particular, it considers the application of the “transferred loss principle” in the context of losses borne by different companies within the same corporate group.
Background Palmali Shipping SA brought a $1.9 billion claim against their charterer, Litasco SA, for losses arising from alleged breaches of a long-term contract of affreightment (CoA).
The issue in dispute arose out of Palmali’s slightly unusual loss calculations. Palmali calculated the profits it would have made under the CoA by assuming that certain shipments would have been performed by ships owned by other companies in its wider corporate group. For shipments onboard those ships, Palmali calculated its lost profit on the basis that it was only required to deduct the cost of bunkers and port charges from the sums payable under the CoA, and was not required to deduct the hire, freight or demurrage it would incur in the use of these ships.
This was contrary to the ship management agreements between Palmali and the intra-group companies, which did provide for these companies to invoice Palmali for freight. However, Palmali argued that, in practice, they would not be required to settle the intra-group debt arising from these freight invoices.
Litasco applied for summary judgment on the quantification of Palmali’s loss of profit claim. Palmali countered this strategy by cross-applying to amend their claim to include recovery of losses incurred by the intra-group companies under the ‘transferred loss’ principle.
Litasco’s summary judgment application was successful.
Download full article.
Newsletter Our newsletter update gives you insight into what's going on in the maritime industry
Subscribe
You are currently offline. Some pages or content may fail to load.